Lockhart hits out at Secretary of State over Stormont Brake rejection

Carla Lockhart MP • November 17, 2026

Carla Lockhart MP, Independent Unionist Member of Parliament for Upper Bann, has criticised the Secretary of State’s decision to reject the Stormont Brake notification submitted by MLAs. She said she will publish a paper next week setting out her position on the Irish Sea Border and how it must be confronted.

Carla Lockhart MP said:


Surprise, surprise. The Secretary of State has rejected the Stormont Brake notification submitted by MLAs.


Once again, he has shown his disregard for unionists, the rule of law and the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom. In his hands, all three come second to settling every issue in favour of nationalists and, on matters like this, pandering to the EU.


The Stormont Brake was sold as a key part of the so-called Safeguarding the Union deal that brought the DUP back into the Executive in 2024. I did not support that deal. Nor did I repeat the blatant falsehood that it would “cut the pipeline of EU law”.


The warnings came from across unionism, including from senior and respected DUP figures with distinguished legal backgrounds, such as Lord Dodds. There was a publicly available legal opinion from our former Attorney General, John Larkin KC. The ERG’s Star Chamber also examined the Stormont Brake as part of its legal assessment of the Windsor Framework.


Those who negotiated and promoted the deal either knew the legal reality or got it badly wrong. The Stormont Brake was fundamentally flawed from the start. In practice, it has proved useless. It has not worked on one solitary occasion.


Those who sold the deal in the face of clear warnings must take responsibility for where it has left us. Northern Ireland’s place in the United Kingdom remains subjugated in law. The pipeline of EU law continues to flow. Worst of all, unionism is now in an Executive implementing this constitutional vandalism.


My position in 2024 was that unionism should have no part in implementing these arrangements. Those who argued that returning to the Executive and using the Stormont Brake would end the flow of EU law won that argument at the time. Their case has now collapsed. What credible argument is left for unionism to help implement arrangements that every unionist agrees are driving us further apart from the rest of the United Kingdom?


On today’s decision, there is no sign that the Secretary of State gave any consideration to section 46 of the UK Internal Market Act 2020. Where is the special regard he is required to give to Northern Ireland’s place in the UK internal market and customs territory?


In his concurring judgment in the Allister case in the Court of Appeal, the late Lord Justice McCloskey examined the effect of the Windsor Framework. With his characteristic clarity, he observed that Northern Ireland “belonged more to the EU market than the UK”. That is becoming more evident by the day.


It is time the UK Government stood up for the territorial and constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom. It is also time unionism stopped passively implementing the very arrangements that are undermining it.


Next week I will publish a paper setting out my position on the Irish Sea Border and how we must confront it. Today’s decision makes that all the more urgent.

Share

By Carla Lockhart MP • November 18, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has tabled an Early Day Motion in the House of Commons congratulating Northern Ireland’s men’s football team on securing promotion to League A of the UEFA Nations League for the first time.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 18, 2026
Carla Lockhart, Independent Unionist MP for Upper Bann, has rejected the deputy Irish prime minister’s vision for a ‘New Ireland’, saying his remarks show how little the Irish Government understands unionist concerns about the rule of law, respect for Protestant traditions and accountability for the past.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 13, 2026
Carla Lockhart MP, Independent Unionist Member of Parliament for Upper Bann, has called on the DUP to clarify whether the Deputy First Minister will take any part in facilitating next Friday’s scheduled meeting of the North–South Ministerial Council.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 11, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has backed calls from the Ulster Farmers’ Union (UFU) for a meaningful and sustained increase in the base price paid to dairy farmers, warning that temporary bonuses must not be used to mask the need for a fairer return for the milk they produce.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 11, 2026
Independent unionist MP Carla Lockhart has welcomed a briefing from the Food Standards Agency (FSA), highlighting the importance of maintaining robust food safety standards, protecting consumers and supporting the integrity of the UK food supply chain.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 11, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has condemned the threatening emails sent to schools across Northern Ireland this morning, describing the incident as deeply concerning and expressing her support for pupils, parents, teachers and school staff affected.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 10, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has said the independent review into the Fivemiletown cattle cull has exposed serious failings within DAERA, but warned that it falls well short of delivering the transparency and accountability demanded by farmers and the wider public.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 8, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has urged farmers across Northern Ireland to make their voices heard as DAERA’s controversial carbon auditing proposals are set to come before the Stormont Assembly on Thursday.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 6, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has criticised Treasury chief secretary Emma Reynolds for suggesting that employers are not working people, warning that her comments demonstrate a worrying lack of understanding of the pressures facing small businesses, family farms and self-employed people.
By Carla Lockhart MP • November 6, 2026
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart is urging the DAERA Minister to revise the rigid rules on the spreading of slurry in Northern Ireland, saying current policy should not come at the expense of common sense.