Committee evidence shouldn’t be based on misinformation or denigration

Carla Lockhart MP • March 5, 2024

Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has said comments made to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee insinuating that pupils attending Controlled Schools might somehow be at risk of wishing to join a paramilitary organisation were outrageous.

The comments were made during an evidence session the Committee is holding on Integrated Education and the DUP MP pointed to other examples where inaccurate language was used during the Committee’s inquiry.


Mrs Lockhart said, “It does nothing to promote either one school sector, or our education system as a whole to hear someone dismiss and denigrate another sector of education. It is particularly dangerous and bizarre however to hear an argument based on an anecdote about what a single pupil allegedly said in a careers class at an unnamed school at some unspecified time in the past.


Any insinuation or suggestion that children who attend Controlled schools as being at risk of recruitment into terrorist organisations is outragous. It does a disservice not just to who attend or have attended Controlled schools, but particularly to the teaching and other staff who are as dedicated and focused on helping our young people get the best start in life as those in every other sector of our education system. I work with schools in my constituency from every single sector and I respect the choice parents make to see their children educated in any of these sectors.


Unfortunately it isn’t the first comment made to the Committee which has been either dismissive or misleading. Just a month ago the Committee was told by an academic giving evidence that “one college (in Northern Ireland) was set up specifically to provide teachers for the state-controlled schools”. This would appear to be a reference to Stranmills College as it was then known, but was either ignorant of the fact, or chose to ignore that Stranmillis was established specifically as a non-denominational college and from its earliest operation, included students from all religious backgrounds.


A lesser example was also to be found in today’s hearing with reference to a ”State Protestant school”, presumably referring to a Controlled school, yet Controlled schools have never had any barriers to entry based on religion. Indeed, in my own Constituency there is at least one Controlled school where pupils from a Protestant background make up just 40% of the enrolment.


I have no doubt that the vast majority of those who support and advocate for integrated schools would not want to see a case built on either misinformation or the denigration of another school sector.  Those who have done so only do a disservice to the cause they purportedly set out to advance.”


 Note:


The comments from today’s evidence session can be viewed here:


https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/a82825aa-b4c6-433f-a372-d1519d64b306?in=09:45:45

Share

By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
The Labour government is in crisis and facing mounting pressure to climbdown on its proposed changes to Agricultural Property Relief (APR) and Business Property Relief (BPR).
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has called on the UK Government to ensure that parents of premature babies are properly supported through parental leave entitlements and has urged Northern Ireland to follow suit with legislative progress that reflects the unique challenges these families face.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart has today issued a scathing criticism of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland following his dismissive response to serious concerns raised in Parliament about the impact of the Windsor Framework on local businesses.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart, has praised the organisers, volunteers, and local community following a highly successful Northern Ireland Kidney Research Fund Vintage Cavalcade held in Waringstown.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart, has strongly criticised the Infrastructure Minister following the latest announcement of part-time 20mph speed limits outside schools with not a single school in Upper Bann included in the new tranche.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart, has paid tribute to the warmth and generosity of the Waringstown community following her visit to a special coffee morning hosted by Evelyn Hall in memory of her late husband, Mervyn, on what would have been his birthday.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 2, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart, has strongly criticised the Infrastructure Minister following the latest announcement of part-time 20mph speed limits outside schools with not a single school in Upper Bann included in the new tranche.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 1, 2025
Upper Bann MP, Carla Lockhart, has strongly condemned the Government’s handling of today’s welfare reform debate, describing the scenes in the House of Commons as “pantomime politics at its best.” The debate on the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Universal Credit Bill was marked by confusion, with significant policy changes announced live from the despatch box, leaving MPs reacting to legislation that was changing before their eyes.
By Carla Lockhart MP July 1, 2025
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart is appealing to livestock farmers in Northern Ireland to remain vigilant as the threat from Bluetongue disease increases.
By Carla Lockhart MP June 26, 2025
Upper Bann MP and DUP Westminster Agriculture Spokesperson Carla Lockhart has tabled an Early Day Motion in the House of Commons opposing the enforcement of burdensome EU regulations on the movement of used agricultural and forestry machinery from Great Britain to Northern Ireland.
More Posts